Extreme Justifications Fuel Polarisation

Christiane Buschinger, Markus Eyting, Florian Hett & Judd B Kessler, 2026,
The Economic Journal,
[Published Online: 23 May, 2026]

Abstract:
How does polarisation—as measured by mistreatment of political rivals—spread? In an online experiment, participants choose between splitting financial resources equally or discriminating against a supporter of the opposing political party. We vary the information that subjects receive about others’ choices and justifications for discrimination. Exposure to extreme justifications for discrimination increases discrimination—particularly in a polarised environment, when many others are already discriminating—and it leads participants to adopt more extreme justifications themselves. Our findings suggest a self-reinforcing dynamic that may fuel polarisation: exposure to extreme statements increases polarisation and the prevalence of extreme reasoning.